The Dakota Way Sales Coaching: November 19, 2026

The Dakota Way Sales Coaching: November 19, 2026
8:21

Hosted by Gui Costin, Founder & CEO, Dakota and Tim Dolan, Vice President, Institutional Sales, Dakota

Watch on YouTube | Listen on Spotify

Executive Summary:

Gui Costin is joined by longtime colleague Tim Dolan to spend most of this month’s session on a single concept, which is rare for the show: cold outreach that books meetings. The idea came from a fundraiser who told Gui that adding a clear call to action to his emails changed everything after 19 years of sending them. Gui and Tim cover the three parts of a cold email, why a specific date, time, and city beats asking the allocator to suggest a time, and the three jobs every email does at once. Gui then closes by running through the four core principles of The Dakota Way, from setting expectations with your boss to building a follow-up system around your CRM and a weekly pipeline report.

Products Discussed in This Episode

Dakota Marketplace

The complete allocator intelligence platform built by fundraisers for fundraisers. Covers institutional and intermediary channels in the US and globally. Real-time updates on job changes, fundraising news, and allocator activity. The Metro Areas feature lets you pull every qualified prospect in a city by channel — the backbone of city scheduling discussed throughout this episode.

↓ Download the Platform Guide

Resources & Documents Mentioned

The Dakota Way by Gui Costin
The only book written on investment sales: 4 core principles for fundraisers.
Available on Kindle and softcover on Amazon.
Request a signed copy

Be Kind by Gui Cosin
The companion workbook to this episode. Use it to build your sales plan, TAM, city scheduling cadence, and opportunity pipeline report.
Available on Kindle and softcover on Amazon.
Request a signed copy

Stacy Havener — Allocator Meeting Masterclass
Referenced in Core Principle 3. Stacy delivers a clinic on how to structure an allocator meeting: centering the conversation in the first two minutes, getting the prospect talking 70% of the time, and asking the two tough questions before you leave.
YouTube | Spotify

This Month’s Focus: Cold Outreach That Books Meetings

Gui has been hosting lunches in cities across the country, and the same themes come up every time: what is working, what is not, and how to send an email. One attendee’s story set up this session. After 19 years of cold outreach, he changed one thing, ending every email with a specific ask such as “I’m going to be in Chicago on May 4th, can you meet at 3 o’clock?”, and said it changed the whole game.

Tim, who sends cold outreach for a living, explains why it works. The purpose of the email is to get a meeting or a call on the books, not an allocation. The answer you want back is a simple yes or no, and the only way to get one is to ask a very clear question.

Gui is blunt about the alternative. Asking someone to send over a few days that work, or saying you will be in town the week of December 7th and asking if they can meet, makes the prospect do all the work. He calls that unkind, which is the thinking behind his book Be Kind.

Every cold email has three parts:

  1. Subject line: “Meeting Request,” or “Meeting Request” plus the date or strategy, such as large-cap growth. Gui opens every one he gets, even though almost all of them are junk, because he wants to know what the sender wants to meet about.

  2. One to three sentences: who you are, what you do, and why they should care. Tim’s example is a real estate credit platform that provides construction financing to multifamily developers. The analyst knows right away whether it fits, and a quick “not a fit” is still an answer. Skip the bullet points.

  3. A clear call to action: “Can you meet in Chicago May 4th at 3 o’clock?” Gui says you can debate whether to offer multiple times, but the format works and the tweaks are up to you.

Gui adds that the email does three jobs at once:

  1. It books the meeting. This is the primary job.

  2. It builds your brand. Allocators get 200 to 300 emails a day, and a consistent “Meeting Request” in their inbox builds awareness over time.

  3. It markets your strategy. Analysts keep Outlook folders named for asset classes such as private equity, hedge funds, private real estate, and private credit. If your first line is clear, they drag your email into the right folder, and if it is not, they move on.

Tim notes that the odds of a reply to a first-ever email are low, so the second and third emails matter as much, each with the same clear call to action. Gui’s rule of thumb for staying consistent is 20 to 25 emails a day and five cities on the calendar at all times. He also reminds fundraisers that nobody went to college to be a professional meeting setup person, but it is the job, so accept it.

The Dakota Way: 4 Core Principles

Gui frames the umbrella concept as focusing on what matters most. This approach has been in use since 2011, he wrote the book in 2025, and the best fundraisers apply it today.

Core Principle 1: Set Expectations with Your Boss

Write a sales plan and set a weekly cadence to meet with your boss and update them on progress against it. Tim sees two benefits. You are always managing up, so your boss never wonders where you are or what you are working on. It also holds you accountable, because you do not want to walk into those meetings with blanks. The meeting is a forcing mechanism for action, meetings on the books, and pipeline movement, all things you can control.

Core Principle 2: Know Who to Call On

Establish your TAM, starting with the investors you know for a fact have invested in your strategy before. Then use city scheduling: always have five cities on the books that you are doing cold outreach to, and when one rolls off, add another. Pair that with the cold outreach structure above and be consistent with it.

Core Principle 3: Be a Master Messenger

Gui notes that the real masterclass in an allocator meeting is whether you can get through nearly an hour without talking about your investment, and instead build a relationship by listening. Short of that, he gives four elements:

  1. Spend two minutes on who you are, what you do, and why they should care. Nail it so the allocator knows what they are listening for.

  2. Ask about their investment decision-making process. Rather than giving a soliloquy on your strategy, say you have studied them and ask them to walk you through it for a couple of minutes. Tim adds that they will often mention who they have used in the past, so you can speak to how you compare and differ.

  3. Have them talk 70% of the time. As Stacy Havener says, most fundraisers talk 90% of the time. Get into a Q&A and a discussion instead.

  4. Leave with the two most important questions to get a status. First, ask whether they see your strategy fitting their asset allocation mix. If no, they go on the mailing list. If yes, a private fund can ask whether they can make the final close date, such as 3/31/27. A public strategy, such as a mutual fund or ETF, can ask whether they anticipate doing a search in the next 12 months.

Core Principle 4: Have a Killer Follow-Up System

Gui calls this the principle that gives you 10x leverage: you need a CRM. Log the meetings you have scheduled, add notes once each meeting is completed, and create opportunities. Run past activity reports to see who you have met with before, which triggers sales actions. Then run an opportunity pipeline report, live in it, and print it out for your weekly sit-down with your boss. That closes the loop back to Core Principle 1.

Bring The Dakota Way to Your Team

Gui closes by opening the floor to teams: he's happy to come in and speak directly to younger fundraisers about the four core principles from the book. If interested, reach out to gui@dakota.com.

September’s Coaching Session is at 1pm on December 17, 2026

30 mins. Practical tactics. No pitch. Build for boutique investment firms raising capital without the budget of a large firm.

Save Your Seat →

View all Sales Coaching episodes

Cate Costin, Marketing Associate

Written By: Cate Costin, Marketing Associate